12 Comments
User's avatar
Dan J Schmidt's avatar

You wrote that 'conservative' meant : "simple ideas: limited government, local control, fiscal restraint, personal responsibility, and the notion that your home and business was your castle, not a place for someone else's theological agenda."

I'm an Idaho Democrat, served in the legislature, and I adhere'd to these values. They reflected mine.

The old political labels are losing their value. We need another way.

Idaho Hazel's avatar

Spot on!

Talia Giordano's avatar

“If your values can’t stand unless someone else is silenced, excluded or punished, they’re not values. They’re insecurities wrapped in a flag and a cross.”

Wow, Gregory. The raw honesty of that statement stopped me in my tracks.

Well said and much appreciated.

Carol Jane's avatar

Thank you, Talia. Now, if only the group who needs to be reading these clarifications would do so. The issue is that they seldom are reached by any broad spectrum of opinion.

Rod Furniss's avatar

Well said

Tom Hearn's avatar

I’m not a Republican conservative but I would consider being one if Idaho Republicans acted as you suggest.

Kimber ''s avatar

Very very well said thank you for that read

Deborah Rose's avatar

Another excellent and much needed message, Greg. We can bring the people knowledge; who of them will be willing to think?

Steven Lester Bunt's avatar

GOP, Republican in "IDAHO"-- "NO", there is only "TRUMPISM", and it began in 2016, actually as far back as 2007 when Trump was bashing Obama,over a Birth Certificate, Trump was also Bashing a Gop Senator John McCain ! Hate, Revenge, Control , Power, RETRIBUTION, "TRUMPISM" is what is in POWER, in IDAHO. And the Entire UNITED STATES.

Please, Try a Google Search of Italy's Mussolini, Germanys Adolph Hitler, and the CONTROL of those NATIONS and the People from late 1920s-- December 1941. ( it was a WORLD WIDE DEPRESSION ) Americans, Idahoan's , the Similarities and actions are to GREAT to IGNORE, "WE the PEOPLE" are Being SEVERELY TESTED, there is NO CONSERVATISM, only "TRUMPISM" !

Carol Jane's avatar

Actually the MAGA-type movement started decades prior to Trump's emergence into politics. Remember the Tea Party who painted posters with Hitler's mustache painted, of all places, on Obama's face? Talk about misinformed. And much earlier than that, I think in the 1950, the "Federalist" Society or movement, also taking a name that did not reflect their positions. Trump was actually amazed when his rantings brought forth such support from vengeance-oriented people who are most swayed by hatred, universally the hook of fascism. Trump then kept his finger in the wind to decide what he would claim as his issues.

Mary Mason's avatar

Ok. So what does a lefty do to stop these heinous people? My vote is no longer counted in this state I love. Ideas?

deborah hennessy's avatar

Register as R to vote in the primaries since the GOP closed its primary to all voters.

I did this to vote for Phil McGrane after he defended the integrity of the 2020 election. It’s the only way to choose the candidate with the experience and character that you want in governing Idaho. Doesn’t make me popular with everyone but it’s worth it!

Great Substack article Greg!